![]()
Return to Home Page Web Hosting donated by Xmission
Xmission is UMA's preferred internet provider
September 2008 Edition
Visit Miners Hospital and Clinic -- Click here
2008 UMA Platinum Convention Sponsors: RIO TINTO ANNOUNCES $270 MILLION INVESTMENT IN MOLYBDENUM Rio Tinto will invest $270 million in the construction of a new Molybdenum Autoclave Process (MAP) facility at its Kennecott Utah Copper (KUC) Bingham Canyon operation in Salt Lake City. This will enable lower-grade concentrate to be processed more efficiently than conventional roasters, allow improved molybdenum recovery and operating flexibility and enable production of chemical grade molybdenum products. Tom Albanese, chief executive of Rio Tinto, said "The outlook for molybdenum demand is very strong, driven by the rapid urbanization and industrialization of China and India. KUC is one of the world's lowest cost producers of copper, and molybdenum and gold production at Bingham Canyon are major contributors to this position." Molybdenum is a by-product of copper production and is used in metal alloys, including steel, to enhance toughness, high-temperature strength and corrosion resistance. It is also a key component in oil refining catalysts used to remove sulphur from fuel and improve air quality. Molybdenum has been a major contributor to the profitability of Rio Tinto's Copper Group in recent years and is likely to continue to be in the future. The investment will enable Rio Tinto to increase revenue, expand molybdenum production, simplify operations, provide flexibility in mine planning and contribute to its sustainable development initiatives. "This capital investment will prove to be a tremendous future benefit to Rio Tinto," said Bret Clayton, chief executive of Rio Tinto's Copper Group. "MAP will provide significant financial upside and allow us to use energy more efficiently, enhancing our environmental stewardship." MAP will also make it possible for Rio Tinto to recover rhenium from its concentrate and become a secure long-term supplier. This is a high-margin market where the average spot price in the last three months was $4,300 per pound. The facility will have a capacity to produce up to 9,000lbs of rhenium per year. The MAP design includes a number of energy conservation features and an environmentally responsible technique for producing molybdenum products. A steam recovery system will be included to capture excess steam from the autoclave for use in downstream processes. This recycle system will supply about 40 percent of the plant's thermal requirements and emit significantly less sulphur dioxide and carbon dioxide by processing molybdenum concentrate through MAP. MAP follows a series of investments to increase long term profitability and accelerate mining operations to meet global demand for natural resources. In 2006, an $82 million investment was announced to expand and modernize the bulk flotation process at KUC's Copperton Concentrator. The project is substantially complete and in start up phase. Earlier this year, a $73 million investment was agreed in mining equipment to accelerate mining activity at the Bingham Canyon Mine and provide options for future mine extensions.
WHEELER MACHINERY COMPANY Since 1951 Wheeler Machinery Co. has been a partner to the Mining Industry, helping them increase profitability by providing mining equipment that affords each customer machines that provide the lowest cost per ton. Wheeler has a set up a Mining Segment dedicated to solely supporting mining customers. Wheeler's Sales Representatives ensure that customers get the highest production possible out of each machine. The Product Support Representatives ensure that the equipment is operating at the lowest possible cost per hour. Together, this team helps customers meet the goal of lowest cost per ton and increased profits. This team has the entire support of Wheeler Machinery Co. behind it, including our complete service department with over 100 field service trucks. Wheeler also offers options of having our servicemen on-site at mines to ensure the shortest down time on equipment. We are currently in the process of building a Certified Rebuild Component center. This center is designed to increase our ability to provide Certified Rebuilt Components to all our customers. Wheeler Machinery Co. has 13 branch locations conveniently located throughout the territory to make parts pick up, equipment service and rental as easy as possible. With the largest rental fleet in Utah consisting of like-new units, lost time due to machine repairs can be minimized. For those interested in GPS and Machine Control and Guidance, Wheeler Machinery Co. offers a large line of technology products from companies such as Caterpillar, Trimble and Rajant. Wheeler Machinery Co. can demonstrate to you how to increase your efficiency with these technology products, and be there to support them every step of the way. At Wheeler, we work hard to provide products and services that are the safest in the marketplace. Wheeleroffers information and materials to help you work safely when you're in, on, or around Cat equipment. Wheeler Machinery Co. is committed to safety for our employees and yours. Wheeler Machinery Co. is your total Mining equipment solution dealer.
AT UTAH MINING ASSOCIATION During the month of September, we watched the financial markets in the United States and the rest of the world teeter on the brink of economic collapse. The nation's subprime mortgage fiasco initiated the "toxic" mortgage problem which was then closely followed by the "soft" derivative investments and market rate auctions. Allegations of who is to blame has fingers pointing at the White House, the U.S. Congress, the regulatory agencies, and even the U.S. public who has benefitted from 20 years of low interest rates. It is clear, however, that much of the financial trauma is the result of total unregulation on Wall Street and the appetite of investment banks to make ever increasing more economic return on riskier and riskier investment packages. These excesses and lack of essential financial market oversight over the past 30 years have led to the severest liquidity and credit crisis since the 1930's. Because of the interconnection of global financial markets, the world may be headed towards a global recession which may take many years – possibly a decade or longer – from which to fully recover. This financial market crisis has in the short term lead precious metal commodity prices for gold, silver, and platinum to advance. Other commodity prices may in fact soften if global economic growth weakens due to a global recession. It appears that Ameicans and other citizens throughout the world are tightening their belts. MINExpo was held in Las Vegas, Nevada, September 22-24, 2008. Attendance at this year's Expo was well above the level of four years ago by over 30% with the number of registrants exceeding 40,000. The exhibits throughout the Las Vegas Convention Center were outstanding, the educational seminars timely and most informative, and the weather terrific. The National Mining Association should be commended for putting on an excellent MINExpo this year. One can only hope that with the economic strains occurring throughout the world, that the mining industry will continue to have strong commodity prices over the next few years. If not, the 2012 MINExpo may not be as exciting or large as this year's tremendous event.
EVENTS
KENNECOTT TO ROOM WITH RIO TINTO Kennecott Utah Copper soon will be leaving its Magna headquarters for new environmentally friendly, energy- efficient digs in South Jordan's Daybreak development. "This move is all about us operating more efficiently," said Andrew Harding, Kennecott Utah Copper's chief executive officer. "As it is, we spend a lot of time commuting between offices. By bringing people together, there is more opportunity for everyone to work more efficiently." In all, about 570 people from Rio Tinto, Kennecott Utah Copper and Kennecott Land will move to the new facility in the Daybreak master-planned community at the foot of the Oquirrh Mountains. The amalgamation of the various offices of Kennecott and Rio Tinto - along with the Magna headquarters there are employees working in Copperton and near Salt Lake City International Airport - is expected to be completed by the end of October. Laura Jo McDermaid, a member of the Magna Community Council, said businesses in the area that serve the approximately 300 employees working at Kennecott's headquarters will definitely feel the impact of the move. "We certainly hate to see them go. Kennecott's headquarters has been here for a long time. They have been very good neighbors." Harding said Kennecott "will continue to support [the Magna community] any way we can." Kennecott headquarters has been in the Arbor Park development near 8400 West and 3500 South in Magna for about a decade, Harding said. "Prior to that our headquarters was in downtown Salt Lake City." Harding pointed out that Kennecott's new headquarters will be in a LEED-certified building. LEED stands for Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design. It is a program of the U.S. Green Building Council that provides an independent third-party verification that a building has been constructed in an environmentally responsible fashion, and is a healthy place to work. Kennecott, along with other affiliated companies such as Kennecott Land, will become part of a new Rio Tinto Regional Center. That center will take up about 137,000 square feet in the 175,000-square-foot Daybreak Corporate Center. "Our goal in constructing that building was to do it in a sustainable manner so we could have a positive impact on the people who will work there," said Scott Schwindeman, of Kennecott Land, the developer of the Daybreak community, a housing, retail and commercial enterprise. He said all the electricity purchased for use in the building will be generated from renewable sources such as solar and wind. The building also has its own solar panels on the roof and water-efficient landscaping.
KENNECOTT NOT PROSPECTING, Copper-mining giant Kennecott may pay an uninvited visit to Salt Lake County's Yellow Fork Park - not to enjoy the open-space value of the county-owned slice of Oquirrh Mountain wilderness, but to determine whether there's mineral value beneath it. Salt Lake County confirmed that it has received notice that Kennecott plans to conduct "casual" mineral exploration on 80 acres of the south-valley expanse. The company may collect rock samples, lay survey wires and inspect the property, but county officials say Kennecott cannot disturb the property physically. That means no trenches, no drilling and no new roads. Mayor Peter Corroon said he won't stand in the company's way. "We are not going to unnecessarily try to block what they are allowed to do legally," he said. "We are not happy with it. But it is within their legal rights." The move comes less than a year after news surfaced that Kennecott wanted to conduct similar studies on the nearby Rose Canyon Ranch. The county bought the property last fall to create one of the largest wedges of preserved wildland on the west side - a swath stretching nearly 4,000 acres (about the size of Holladay) when combined with Yellow Fork Park and a neighboring Bureau of Land Management parcel. Yet Kennecott's action in Yellow Fork appears triggered by the county's recent push to acquire mineral rights beneath Rose Canyon to guard against encroachment by ore seekers. Kennecott spokesman Matt Jeschke said the company simply is protecting its mineral-exploration interests in the area, despite county resistance. "It has been our hope to work cooperatively and collaboratively with the county on the property," he said. "But the request for withdrawal [of mining claims in Rose Canyon] forces our hand." Even so, Salt Lake County Open Space Coordinator Lorna Vogt said the copper giant's latest claim poses no immediate threat to the property. Long term? "It is far too early to speculate," she said. "The county will take the measures allowed by the law to protect its land for open space." Corroon said the county will continue to pursue the purchase of mineral rights beneath its Oquirrh Mountain holdings. "Our intent," the mayor said, "is to keep it for the citizens to use as natural open space."
TWO MINING FIRMS CREATE Two mining companies have established a joint venture to develop a porphyry copper, gold and molybdenum mine in the Tintic Mining District of Juab County. Chief Consolidated Mining Co. and Anglo American US (Utah) Inc. said Wednesday they had created Big Hill LLC to explore veins of quartz for the targeted metals. Anglo American will own 55 percent of the company. Chief Consolidated, which currently owns the claims, will retain the rest. Anglo American expects exploratory drilling to begin this month.
FIRM GETS LAND AGENCY'S Federal officials have approved the reopening and combining of two reclaimed underground uranium mines on the Utah-Colorado line. The U.S. Bureau of Land Management in Moab and Grand Junction, Colo., announced Friday that Lakewood, Colo.-based Energy Fuels Resources would combine the Urantah Decline and Packrat Mine into an operation called the Whirlwind Mine. Earlier the agency released an environmental assessment that showed the mine would have no significant impact. The Energy Fuels plan allows for up to 200 tons per day of uranium production, which would yield a quarter-ton annually of U308 to be processed to yellow cake in Blanding in southeastern Utah's, home to the nation's only conventional uranium mill. Energy Fuels is a Toronto-based uranium and vanadium mineral-development company that claims more than 40,000 acres of highly prospective uranium and vanadium property located in Utah, Colorado and Arizona. Uranium prices on the spot market currently are about $65 per pound, down from about $90 in December.
UTAH BUSINESS OWNER HONORED FOR SUPPORTING THE TROOPS WASHINGTON - The owner of a small trucking company in Salina, Utah, is receiving praise this week from the Pentagon and President Bush. Kim Robinson's company earned the government's highest recognition given to employers for "exceptional support" for Guard and Reserve employees. Robinson said his efforts weren't about garnering attention or honors, but about taking care of his employees called up to serve abroad. Robinson's company, Robinson Transport, was one of 15 to receive the Freedom Award for going above and beyond to help out the troops. Robinson was scheduled to receive the award Thursday night at a black-tie ceremony at the Ronald Reagan Building and International Trade Center in downtown Washington. "It's just like a dream," Robinson said Thursday. "It's awesome. I can't really explain how I feel. It's a great honor by all means." His company was nominated and chosen for the award for Robinson's decision to pay each employee ordered to active duty a salary of $1,000 per month, all health benefits as well as a bonus for Christmas for each family. Employers legally are only required to hold open the job while an employee is serving on active duty. Thursday, Robinson and several family members were treated to a tour of the Pentagon and a meeting with a top official there. Robinson still downplays his efforts. "We just did it to do it," he said. "Sometimes we look how awesome we really have it in America," he added. And, "That's just a small token of appreciation for those guys. They're over there fighting for their lives and our freedoms and, you know, I don't think they need to worry about how their wife's going to make it, or [how they'll afford] their house payment or their kids and stuff." Gordon Sumner, executive director of the National Committee for Employer Support of the Guard and Reserve, praised Robinson for his work. "In the military, the best leaders are those who always take care of their people - and it is no different in the civilian workplace," Sumner said. "Robinson Transport has shown that it, too, takes care of its people."
NEVADA CHEMICALS SALE A shareholder of Sandy-based Nevada Chemicals Inc. is trying to block a proposed $94 million buyout of the company that produces sodium cyanide for the gold mining industry. Nevada Chemicals earlier this month announced it had signed an acquisition agreement with Calypso Acquisition Corp. and a fund managed by the U.S. private equity firm Oaktree Capital Management that want to buy the company through a $13.37 per share tender offer. However, shareholder Irving S. Braun in a proposed class action lawsuit filed in Utah's 3rd District Court contends the offering price is inadequate and argues several of the company's top executives failed to disclose all the information necessary for shareholders to make an informed decision. Braun is demanding Nevada Chemicals retain "truly" independent advisers or appoint an independent special committee to ensure shareholders receive a "fair process and fair price in connection with any transaction" involving the company. He is represented by the Salt Lake City law firm of Anderson & Karrenberg. Nevada Chemicals was founded in 1979. It owns a 50 percent interest in a plant near Winnemucca, Nev., that produces sodium cyanide. The chemical is used in a gold recovery process known as heap leaching. In the process, ground ore is placed upon an impermeable pad and a diluted solution of sodium cyanide, which attaches itself to gold molecules, is allowed to percolate down through the ground rock. The solution is collected and the gold removed. Nevada Chemicals Chief Executive John Day takes exception to the allegations in the lawsuit, which he argues was filed before the details of the tender offer were filed Monday with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Com- mission. "All the details of the transaction, its history and how it evolved are now on file with the SEC," Day said. "We also hired an independent outside examiner to give us a fairness opinion on the transaction." He also noted the $13.37 price offered for each of the company's 7 million outstanding shares represented a 36 percent premium over the closing stock market price of Nevada Chemical's stock on the day the buyout was announced. Nevada Chemical's shares have not traded as high as $13.37 for at least the past 15 years, according to data from Bloomberg News.
RSL: RIO TINTO A PERFECT MATCH SANDY - From start to finish, it only took 42 days for Real Salt Lake and Rio Tinto to reach an agreement to put the mining giant's name on the soccer team's new stadium. Evidence, said Real Salt Lake owner Dave Checketts, that the partnership was meant to be. And why not, he added at Monday's formal unveiling of naming rights for the $110 million stadium. Rio Tinto's local subsidiary, Kennecott Utah Copper, has been a major mover-and-shaker in the Salt Lake Valley for more than a century. And while the parent company's name may not be well-known here, it is all around the soccer-loving world, from its headquarters in London to its mining operations on every inhabited continent. "We have found, in every way, the perfect partner," said Checketts in a ceremony on the north plaza of the stadium, which will open Oct. 9 with a nationally televised RSL game against New York. That plaza soon will be equipped with powerful spotting scopes that will afford close-up views across the Salt Lake Valley of Rio Tinto's most visible local asset, the Bingham Canyon mine. Neither Checketts nor Rio Tinto Copper CEO Brett Clayton would discuss the value or length of the naming rights contract, citing confidentiality clauses in the agreement. Kennecott spokeswoman Jana Kettering disputed the accuracy of Salt Lake Tribune sources who put the figure at $1.5 million to $2 million annually for 15 years. She declined to provide alternate numbers. All Checketts would say is "it's a very good deal for both sides." From Real Salt Lake's perspective, said team president Bill Manning, the association with "a world-class company gives us credibility." For Rio Tinto, having its name on the stadium will enhance the company's ongoing efforts to establish its name more vividly in the public consciousness, following up on its sponsorship of the new Utah Museum of Natural History, which will be known as the Rio Tinto Center. "This sponsorship is one way of giving back to a community where we live and work," said Kennecott Utah Copper President Andrew Harding. "We're here to stay." As late as mid-July, however, the naming rights issue was up in the air. Checketts said he had been involved in preliminary discussions with three other companies when he got a call from an old friend - Richard Horne, executive director of the R. Harold Burton Foundation - suggesting Rio Tinto. Horne noted that its copper division was headed by Clayton, a Skyline High School and University of Utah graduate. Checketts called him. A meeting was arranged. Over the next six days, two more meetings were held with different mining company executives. RSL's Manning and Rio Tinto's Gina Crezée then hammered out the initial details, basically reaching a deal by Sept. 8, subject to dotting I's and crossing T's on the final contract. Besides providing "a really cool name for a stadium - Real at Rio," Checketts said the now-finalized partnership conjured up childhood memories for him of watching movies on television during "Kennecott Neighborhood Theater," of peering down into the open-pit mine on Cub Scout trips and marveling at the height of the Kennecott Building in downtown Salt Lake City. Now, he predicted, the stadium's name "will be part of countless childhood memories for years to come." FINES SLAPPED ON MINE OPERATORS LEAP 141% After a string of high-profile mine accidents in Utah and other states that left dozens dead in recent years, coal Operators say the federal Mine Safety and Health Administration has become extremely heavy-handed in an attempt to counteract accusations of lax oversight. During the first 10 months of fiscal 2008, MSHA says it has slapped mine operators with Producers say the spike in enforcement actions have stifled. productivity, increased costs and prevented mine operators from cashing in on soaring international demand. Prices, particularly for metallurgical-grade coal for powering steel blast furnaces, have tripled in the past year in response to the weak U.S. dollar, foreign shipping bottlenecks, ocean freight rates and other factors. Met coal has fetched $250 a ton at times, while spot prices for coal for electric utilities have tripled in Appalachia and the Illinois Basin. Still, signs that Massey Energy Co., Arch Coal Inc., Alpha Natural Resources, Murray Energy Co. and other U.S. Producers were chafing under the oversight began about a year ago, just as MSHA was drawing renewed criticism from Congress and organized labor over enforcement. Critics blasted the agency for failing to perform mandatory inspections at underground coal mines despite high-profile fatal accidents including the Sago Mine explosion in 2006 that killed 12 and the Crandall Canyon mine collapse and rescue attempt that killed nine. "Some of these citations or violations are extremely petty and probably in no way contribute to safer conditions," said National Mining Association- spokesman Luke Popovich. MSHA Director Richard Stickler dismisses the notion that stricter enforcement isn't improving safety. "Certainly when you find an unsafe condition and you require the operator to correct that condition, that has to be making the mine safer," Stickler said. MSHA's own statistics show the agency began upping the pressure beginning in 2007. Citations and orders issued for various infractions jumped 2 percent, to 78,687, from fiscal 2006 and 2007. Through the first 10 months of fiscal 2008, MSHA says citations and orders were up 7.7 percent to 84,744. Fines doubled to $40.4 million from fiscal 2006 to 2007 before this year's big increase. Stickler said the agency was able to hire 170 inspectors and also cited federal legislation allowing increased fines across the board for better regulation.
MSHA CALLS FOR CRIMINAL PROBE Safety violations uncovered in its formal investigation of last year's Crandall Canyon mine disaster warrant a criminal probe by the U.S. Attorney for Utah, the federal Mine Safety and Health Administration said Wednesday. An MSHA statement did not elaborate on the scope of the agency's request to U.S. Attorney for Utah Brett Tolman, noting only that the criminal referral "arises out of the same facts, events and conditions that led to MSHA's issuance of civil citations and orders on July 24." That was the day MSHA released its official investigation into last August's disaster. Six coal miners were fatally buried by a catastrophic implosion of the mine's walls on Aug. 6, 2007. Ten days later, three would-be rescuers were killed and six injured by a second violent outburst. MSHA's report assessed fines of $1.34 million against the mine operator, Murray Energy Co. subsidiary Genwal Resources Inc., for alleged safety violations that contributed directly to the first six miners' deaths. MSHA also levied a $220,000 fine against Agapito Associates Inc., the mining company's engineering consultant, for allegedly providing faulty analysis of the mine's design. "MSHA determined that the operator and its engineering consultants demonstrated reckless disregard for safety," said agency director Richard Stickler. Melodie Rydalch, spokeswoman for the U.S. Attorney's Office, would not say Wednesday whether a criminal investigation has been initiated. But she noted that experienced prosecutors in the office have known since the disaster that Crandall Canyon featured "circumstances that we may need to look at." Rydalch also observed that this is the second criminal referral related to Crandall Canyon - the first was made in April by Rep. George Miller, D-Calif., chairman of the House Education and Labor Committee - and that requests from federal agencies and Congress "carry a lot of weight and we take them seriously. But it's important for us to look at the information independently and take it where it goes. We do it all the time." She did add, however, that the "families of the miners deserve a complete investigation." Kevin Anderson, a Salt Lake City attorney representing the mining company, said late Wednesday the referral "comes as no surprise. . . given the profound bias and factual leaps reflected in MSHA's own report [and] highlighted by the Department of Labor's independent review." A Labor Department report, also issued July 24, was highly critical of MSHA's performance before the collapse and during the deadly rescue. "MSHA continues to point fingers at others when its own conduct is under scrutiny," he added. "Mr. Stickler's statement is itself reckless, irresponsible and without factual basis. The facts demonstrate that Genwal Resources Inc. endeavored in good faith to follow safe mining practices and truly believed the mine was safe - a belief that was shared at the time by MSHA itself." MSHA said the U.S. Attorney's Office asked the agency to seek a stay of all civil proceedings, including discovery, related to the disaster. So far, two civil lawsuits have been filed against the mine's owners, operators and consultants by heirs of the dead miners and the injured rescuers. Colin King and Edward Havas, Salt Lake City attorneys representing many of the plaintiffs, applauded the referral. "We are glad to see that the lapses in judgment and implementation of poor mining practices that led to these men being killed and injured are acknowledged as egregious enough to merit consideration for action as serious as this," Havas said. But they also opposed the request to suspend action in the pending civil cases as being unfair to the victims' families. Anderson, Genwal Resources' attorney, also objected. He contended it suppresses "the public's access to the very information MSHA claims supports its sensational allegations."
MSHA REQUIRES LONGER LASTING EQUIPMENT Mine rescue teams will be required to have longer lasting equipment under a final rule published Tuesday by the federal Mine Safety and Health Administration. Key provisions require rescue teams to have self-contained breathing apparatuses that last four hours, instead of two; two extra oxygen bottles, rather than one, for every six breathing apparatuses; and eight hours - up from six - of liquid air, liquid oxygen, pressurized oxygen or oxygen-generating chemicals and carbon dioxide-absorbent chemicals for breathing apparatuses. It also requires four gas detectors for each gas that may be encountered in a mine accident.
Return to Top of Page
JUDGE PULLS PLUG ON A 6th District Court judge ruled Tuesday to pull a power-plant referendum off Sevier County's ballot. "We're quite pleased with the judge's decision," said Fred Finlinson, an attorney for Sevier Power Co. According to Finlinson, Judge Wallace Lee ruled from the bench shortly after hearing oral arguments at the Richfield courthouse, using a new state law as the basis for his decision. With SB53, "the Legislature determined that the initiative process does not apply to the changing of a zoning ordinance," Finlinson said. For several months, Sevier County residents - led by Elaine Bonavita's Right to Vote Committee - fought to put construction of the proposed coal-fired power plant to a public vote. The Right To Vote committee submitted more than 1,500 signatures two days before SB53 took effect May 5. In July, Sevier County Commissioners allowed the referendum to advance to the ballot, but juggled terminology in a way that could have rendered it invalid. "It was an unexpected and disappointing result," said Jeff Owen, the attorney representing the Right To Vote effort. "Judge Lee felt that SB53 was in effect at the time of our initiative because the County Commission took no action on it until July 7," Owens said. "I disagree. On May 3, my clients did the last thing they could possibly do and it was out of their hands at that point." Judge Lee did not rule on whether SB53 is constitutional, choosing instead to leave that up to the state Supreme Court, which will deal with the BRAVE v. Beaver County case concerning the proposed Mount Holly ski and golf resort. Before SB53 took effect, the state attorney general's office advised that courts might strike the new law down as being unconstitutional because of its limits on local initiative and referendum powers. Sevier County residents associated with the Right To Vote effort are considering an appeal, Owens said. In the meantime, Sevier Power Co. will pursue further county approvals and also faces a state Supreme Court battle with the Sierra Club over air quality issues. That appeal is scheduled for early October, Finlinson said. ENERGY
BLM PLAN SAYS A long-term blueprint for managing public lands near Price makes clear that energy development is the top priority - and that's fine with county officials who believe their share of the revenues will make possible a more diverse economy in the future. The U.S. Bureau of Land Management on Friday released its final environmental impact statement and proposed land-use plan for 2.5 million acres in Carbon and Emery counties that emphasizes an energy economy. At the same time, it eliminated virtually any possibility that nearly 1 million acres previously found to have wilderness traits would ever be managed or protected as such. Carbon County Commissioner Bill Krompel hadn't seen the proposed resource-management plan on Friday, but said the county absolutely depends on energy revenues for its current needs and as a source of other types of employment when the oil and gas are gone. "If you look at the top 10 property taxpayers in Carbon County, nine of them are natural gas or coal," he said. Added to mineral-lease royalties and severance taxes that benefit the region and the state, "that's millions and millions of dollars," he said. Rural energy-rich counties have trust funds to sock away the money for the time when the coal, oil and gas run out. "All the rural counties must diversify our economy," Krompel said. The BLM Price field office released its draft management plan four years ago. Last year, due to a federal court order, the BLM wrote a supplement that took a new look at 937,000 acres of wilderness-quality lands. The agency had found the lands worthy of protection in a repeat survey a decade ago but never added to the list of designated wilderness study areas established in the 1970s. The final environmental study includes just 97,000 acres of the wilderness-quality lands - which still will be open to off-road vehicle recreation and oil and gas drilling, with certain restrictions. "Both ORV and drilling are going to destroy wilderness characteristics," said Nada Culver, senior counsel for The Wilderness Society. "There is no prohibition on new roads." A Bush administration study released in May re-emphasized policies established in 2000 that would speed carbon-based energy development with minimal restraints unless federal public-land managers found it "absolutely necessary" to preserve other resources. The Bush policy broadly defines "obstacles" to drilling, which include well-established environmental protection law, municipal development, private-property concerns, wildlife and even national parks. And that's the policy that guided the BLM in the Price study's proposal for wilderness-quality lands and motorized off-road travel, said field office associate director Mike Stiewig. The Energy Policy and Conservation Act "does direct us to try to develop our high-potential areas," he said. "It's not a matter of right or wrong, whether I believe in it or not. That is what the current position is." Maybe so, said Liz Thomas, an attorney with the Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance. But to her, the policy contradicts fundamental BLM legal requirements, which direct the BLM to minimize harm and user conflict while planning for public use of the land that belongs to all. "Protect first, then minimize," Thomas said. "Providing access [must] come under those two caveats."
UTILITY TO UTAH: Rocky Mountain Power is giving Utahns an ultimatum: Give us the money we want or we won't give you the electricity you need. The company that three weeks ago received permission from state utility regulators to raise its rates by $36.1 million, or 2.6 percent, now says that isn't nearly enough. And if it doesn't get more, Utah must face the consequences. "This isn't a threat," Rocky Mountain Power spokesman Dave Eskelsen said. "When the laws of man go against the laws of physics, the laws of physics always win. And generating electricity is all about physics." Rocky Mountain Power expressed its frustration late Tuesday with the Utah Public Service Commission's decision to give it $36.1 million instead of the $74.4 million it demanded. The company said it intends to file a challenge to the commission's order. "The cost of providing for increased electric consumption by existing customers and the cost of providing service to new customers has exceeded the revenue the company receives," Richard Walje, president of Rocky Mountain Power, said in announcing what was termed a change in the way the company services its Utah customers. The company says as a result of the PSC's action, it no longer will be able to operate its system as it has in the past. Rocky Mountain Power said that beginning Sept. 15 when its customers' power goes out it isn't going to authorize any of its employees to work overtime to get the electricity back up. It also is going to cut back on the maintenance of its system and will implement a hiring freeze for any positions that involve serving customers. Michele Beck, director of the state's Committee of Consumer Services, said at first glance it appears that Rocky Mountain Power is launching an attack against Utah consumers. "I'm not sure you can take it [the company's statement] any other way," she said. "They obviously appear upset by what I consider the proper oversight of the company by Utah's utility regulators and consumer advocates." The Committee of Consumer Services, which serves as the voice for consumers and small business owners in utility rate cases, had argued that Rocky Mountain Power only deserved an $8.5 million rate increase. Rocky Mountain Power's warnings led Utah Senate President John Valentine, R-Orem, to express sympathy and appreciation for the utility. "I applaud Rocky Mountain Power for its efforts to take all the other steps first before they start looking at curtailing service," said Valentine, who was attending the Republican National Convention in Minnesota. "Unfortunately, there is no free lunch. And if the revenues are not enough to provide the level of services that are being demanded by our growing market, the options that Rocky Mountain Power have are limited." Valentine said he hopes the PSC will "carefully" review the utility's appeal. "If you cannot provide the service, then the PSC needs to recognize that the cost of providing [electricity] has to be included within rates." But Roger Ball, a longtime utility watchdog and former director of the Utah Committee of Consumer Services, said Walje's statement that the company isn't generating enough revenue to cover its costs is nothing more than an attempt by the utility to get legislators to strong-arm the PSC. When Rocky Mountain Power filed its rate case in December, Ball said the company reported that if its current rates remained unchanged from July 2008 to June 2009 that it would earn 5.8 percent for its shareholders. "And that doesn't even take into consideration the 2.6 percent increase in revenue they were just given," said Ball, who now heads a consumer group known as the Utah Ratepayers Alliance. "So for Rocky Mountain Power to say, as they are now doing, that their revenues are not covering their costs is a blatant lie." Rocky Mountain Power spokesman Dave Eskelsen argued as the result of the PSC's action the utility "is left with some pretty bad choices." And the company indicated that it intends to work closely with state legislators and if necessary will ask lawmakers to force Utahns to participate in company-sponsored programs aimed at reducing the amount of electricity its customers use. -- Thomas Burr contributed to this story.
UTILITY'S ULTIMATUM JOLTS CUSTOMERS Rocky Mountain Power's recent threat that it might curtail its service and let power outages linger longer than necessary is not sitting well with the company's biggest customers. Two groups representing the state's largest power users- the Utah Association of Energy Users and the Utah Industrial Energy Users - are taking exception to company statements they say appear designed to cause fear and concern among Utahns and to be critical of state utility regulators. "We believe the recent order by the Public Service Commission granting [Rocky Mountain Power] a $36 million rate increase was fair and doesn't warrant the kind of dramatic statements they issued," said Gary Dodge, a Utah attorney who represents the Utah Association of Energy Users. The utility, frustrated that the PSC didn't give in to its demands, last week gave Utahns a shocking and unexpected ultimatum: Give us the money we want or we won't give you the electricity you need. Officials for Rocky Mountain Power went on to contend that the PSC, by allowing it to raise its rates by only 2.6 percent, was signaling that low electricity rates for consumers was more important than reliable service. Dodge and Robert Reeder, who serves as counsel for the Utah Industrial Energy Users, represent companies such as Intermountain Health Care, Kennecott Utah Copper and Tesoro Refining. They pointed out the PSC's order was the result of an eight-month process that included dozens of expert witness, hundreds of exhibits and lengthy hearings. They said the PSC consistently allows the power company to recover the costs it incurs, ensuring that its system can provide reliable service to its customers, as well as allowing it to earn a reasonable profit. The PSC order allowing Rocky Mountain Power to raise its rates by $36 million will allow the company to continue to do so, they said. In response, Rocky Mountain Power spokesman Dave Eskelsen said ''because we have now filed a petition with the commission for reconsideration, it would not be proper for the company to comment on the release.'' Reeder said the utility had a chance to make the case for a bigger rate increase. "But their numbers just didn't pass the credibility test with the regulators. They really shouldn't be upset with them [the PSC] because it didn't believe their numbers." Dodge noted that the utility has asked the PSC to reconsider its decision. "It has every right to do it and it is the proper way for them to go about contesting the commission's order." The PSC has 30 days to grant Rocky Mountain Power's request for reconsideration. If it doesn't act, the company can appeal the order to the Utah Supreme Court.
PICKENS PUSHES ENERGY AUTONOMY Energy tycoon T. Boone Pickens says his effort to wean the United States from its dependence on foreign oil - a proposal now known as the "Pickens Plan" - grew out of 40 years of frustration with the nation's politicians. In 1970, the U.S. imported 24 percent of its oil. Today, the amount is nearly 70 percent, which will continue to grow unless something is done, he said. "I just got tired of it. Every time someone would run for president, and it started with Richard Nixon, they'd say elect me and we'll be energy independent. But nothing ever changed. It only got worse." In June, with the nation's presidential candidates making the same promises he had heard before, the billionaire oilman expressed his frustration to his wife. "She told me that if I felt that strongly about it I should go to the people and let them know what the problem is and talk about how it can be fixed," Pickens said. He unveiled his plan and launched his Web site, www.pickensplan.com, July 8. As part of his campaign to cut the nation's demand for foreign oil by a third or more in less than a decade, Pickens will be in Salt Lake City today for a free Town Hall Meeting, where he will discuss what he calls the biggest crisis facing America today. "There isn't a whole lot to it [the Pickens Plan], but it can make a big difference," he said. It calls for the nation to invest in wind-power generation, which could replace the 22 percent of the nation's natural gas production that is being used to produce electricity. That natural gas could then be shifted for use as a transportation fuel. "My critics say that here's this free-market guy who is out looking for government help," Pickens said. "But that isn't the case." He believes that with the right incentives in place, such as production tax credits to help foster wind-power generation and the government encouraging the nation's trucking fleets to convert to natural gas, most of the cost would be picked up by private enterprise. "I want the trucks" to convert to natural gas first, he said, indicating that would foster the development of natural gas refueling stations along the nation's major highways. In turn, this would send a signal to automakers to produce more passenger cars that run on natural gas. Stephen Bloch, conservation director and attorney for the Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance, said the Pickens Plan sounds like an interesting strategy. "The question here in Utah is where you're going to get the natural gas from," Bloch said. "While the vast majority of natural gas wells drilled in the state go unchallenged by environmental groups, there are a few small sensitive areas where we wouldn't want to see development." For Utah's Questar Gas, which has developed one of the nation's best infrastructures for fueling natural gas vehicles, there is a lot to like about the Pickens Plan. "We especially like the part that deals with the increasing use of natural gas as a transportation fuel," spokesman Darren Shepherd said. "It is something that we've been trying to encourage for years." Pickens, who made millions in the oil and gas business and as a corporate raider, is heavily invested in natural gas and wind power. He contends, though, that he isn't promoting his plan for personal gain. "I'm doing it for the country. I've got enough money."
ENSURING AFFORDABLE ELECTRICITY There is no sugarcoating the emerging power crisis faced by Utahns and other Americans. Our political leaders must develop a national energy policy that funds the development of new technologies to keep electricity affordable while meeting climate change goals. Otherwise, a growing number of consumers here and around the country won't be able to pay for power and many might have no power at all. In the past five years, utility bills nationwide have risen 30 percent, largely because of the cost of coal, liquid natural gas and basic construction materials such as steel, concrete and copper. Some Americans have seen rates jump 60 percent or more. At the same time, electricity demand is increasing. In some regions - Utah and the rest of the West in particular - demand will soon outstrip supply. The North America Electric Reliability Corporation, which oversees reliability of the U.S. electric power grid, is projecting that by next year the Western United States will be at risk for blackouts because of the lack of available power. The electric utility sectors in Utah face a double-whammy. We need to build additional power plants to thwart potential electricity shortages. At the same time, we are told to add renewable resources that are more costly than conventional coal-fired power generation because the global warming movement has slowed construction of coal-fired power plants. Just how much additional power generation is needed? A new report by the U.S. Department of Agriculture found that electric cooperatives will have to double their power generation capacity by 2020 if they are to keep up with demand. These crucial issues will be at the top of the agenda when more than 400 officials from over 50 cooperative electric utilities in nine states convene in St. George Monday to address the energy crisis facing our country. The attendees at a regional meeting of the National Rural Electric Cooperative Association will call on our political leaders to fund development of new technologies that ensure the affordability and supply of electricity while meeting national climate change goals. They will outline a strategy for the next president and for Congress, including these recommendations:
Congress and either President Barack Obama or President John McCain will face a historic opportunity to tame this looming energy crisis. If they can't, then America could return to a time when electricity becomes an unaffordable luxury available only to a fortunate few. -- Glenn English is CEO of the National Rural Electric Cooperative Association, which represents more than 900 cooperative electric utilities. Doug Holgate is the board president of the Utah Association of Electric Cooperatives.
HOUSE OKS HUNT FOR OIL SHALE WASHINGTON - Utah and other Western states could open up vast fields of oil shale for development under a measure put forward by Rep. Jim Matheson and passed by the House. Matheson's provision permits Utah, Colorado and Wyoming to choose whether to allow companies to extract what supporters insist is a large source of energy locked in rock deposits in the region. Opponents argue harvesting that energy would be environmentally damaging and isn't commercially viable. The Utah Democrat's insert - tucked inside an energy bill that passed Tuesday night 236-189 - would bypass a ban on finalizing the rules on how oil-shale leases on federal lands are doled out. The current ban expires Oct. 1 but is likely to be renewed. "I don't want to oversell that production is ready - that you're going to see production tomorrow," Matheson said Tuesday. "I understand there are technological advances that are going to have to happen. But I thought it was important for the state and industry to have the opportunity to pursue those resources." Matheson voted for the overall bill, which includes opening up some offshore drilling at a coastal state's discretion, while Utah's GOP representatives, Rob Bishop and Chris Cannon, voted against it. Republicans maintain the energy measure doesn't go far enough to unshackle domestic energy production. Utah Gov. Jon Huntsman Jr. and legislative leaders have supported moving forward on oil-shale leases, although the governors of Colorado and Wyoming oppose rushing into such a program. The majority of the oil shale exists along Colorado's Western Slope, though supporters say millions of barrels of oil could be recovered in eastern Utah's Uinta Basin. Matheson's provision still would leave oil-shale leases subject to federal environmental assessments. The debate now heads to the Senate, where opponents may stall action on the election-year measure. But Matheson hopes it can get through the upper chamber. "An energy bill is going to have to move through this Congress," he said, "and there's a lot of pressure to move it in the next couple weeks." If Congress does adopt the bill, Utah officials will be ready to pass a law opting in. "I would anticipate that the Legislature would welcome the ability to develop that resource," Utah Senate President John Valentine, R-Orem, said Tuesday. "The citizens of Utah deserve to have [the state's] resources developed." But critics contend the technological know-how to extract energy from oil shale is lacking and, even if it was available, the process could take more than 10 years to be commercially viable. Oil shale is actually sedimentary rock that, when heated, produces a mixture of chemical compounds called kerogen, which proponents say can be processed into synthetic oil that can be used for jet and diesel fuel. But the process is costly because the kerogen requires more processing than crude oil. The Wilderness Society says Matheson's language is "unnecessary and unfortunate." Dave Alberswerth, a senior policy adviser at the Washington-based environmental group, notes even the Interior Department has said it's not ready to begin commercial leasing and that the government should wait until it knows how several tests turn out before opening up more lands. "Shouldn't we wait until we have the results of the research and development that's going on before we decide?" Alberswerth asked. "It's completely irresponsible and Congress really should not allow this to happen."
OIL SHALE GETS GREEN LIGHT BECAUSE CONGRESS DIDN'T ACT WASHINGTON - Oil shale production on federal lands in the West will be allowed to move forward starting Monday after Congress failed to re-enact a ban on finalizing a leasing program. But some Democrats warned Wednesday they may replace moratoriums as soon as Congress reconvenes in January. Congress' decision to let the moratorium lapse brought cheers from companies seeking to turn the rock deposits in Utah, Colorado and Wyoming into synthetic fuel. "It's good for the industry," says Jeff Hartley, a consultant to several Utah-based energy companies. "It's really good for the state of Utah." But Hartley argued that if the ban resumes in three months the American people would suffer. "Obviously that would be to the detriment of the American energy consumer and the federal and state treasuries," Hartley said, referencing the royalties. The Democratic-controlled Congress backed down from efforts to push through its own package allowing some oil drilling off American coasts and allowing states to choose whether to pursue oil shale extraction in the face of a threatened White House veto. The current ban on finalizing an oil shale leasing program for federal lands ends Sunday night, allowing the Interior Department to push through draft rules already in the pipeline. Rep. Jim Matheson, D-Utah, who had pushed for a relaxation of moratoriums on off-shore drilling and oil shale development, hailed the expected outcome. "We need to find more oil in our country and Utah's resources are a key part of that effort," he said. Sen. Bob Bennett, R-Utah, called the expiration a victory for Utah and the West. "I've always said [to oil shale critics], 'What are you afraid of?' " Bennett said. "You're afraid it might work. And it's very clear, given the price of $4 a gallon gas, that people want to find out." But three Colorado Democrats claimed the Bush administration threatened a veto of an omnibus spending bill, and they vowed to try to re-enact the moratorium on an oil shale leasing program as soon as Congress returns in January. The White House actually has not taken a position on the budget bill, though it did threaten to veto a House-passed energy package. Oil shale critics, including major environmental groups, charge that no company has shown it has the technology to be commercially viable, that such a process is still more than a decade away and that the production of oil shale might soak up much-needed water in the arid West. -- Matt Canham contributed to this story.
GREENS CAN ENTER CASE OVER ROADS IN JUAB Three conservation organizations will be allowed to intervene in a case in which Juab County and the state sued the federal government over who owns three roads in western Utah's Deep Creek Mountains. U.S. District Judge Tena Campbell this week granted the Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance, the Sierra Club and The Wilderness Society the right to be defendants in the lawsuit in which the state and county seek ownership of the roads. Campbell agreed with the conservationists' arguments that they cannot rely on federal land agencies to adequately represent their defense of wilderness in cases involving a Civil War-era law known as Revised Statute 2477. "Conservationists now will have a seat at the table on these RS2477 claims," SUWA conservation director Heidi McIntosh said Thursday. "We will be in the courthouse instead of standing on the steps with the doors locked." But the state doesn't believe the organizations should be allowed to intervene since they had no claim of ownership at all. "We're disappointed in the ruling," said Assistant Utah Attorney General Roger Fairbanks. Bureau of Land Management state office spokeswoman Mary Wilson declined to comment because the lawsuit remains active. At issue is how federally designated wilderness-study areas ought to be managed so as to preserve the special qualities of beauty and remoteness that led the BLM to list them in the first place. Roads that cross wilderness or wilderness-quality lands have become flash points in an increasingly polarized dispute. Key to wilderness status is whether the land is roadless, which does not mean literally unmarked. Rather, the BLM in its survey of potential wilderness tracts limited study areas to those where there were no "substantially noticeable" roads. McIntosh said the BLM wouldn't have included Tom's Creek, Granite Canyon and Trout Creek canyon roads in wilderness-study areas had they been well-established. Further, she said, they are not part of the state's transportation highway network. Fairbanks said SUWA was assigning a modern definition to a 19th-century highway statute. Back in 1866, he said, there were no paved roads. "Highways were wagon trails," Fairbanks said. "These roads are part of Juab County's highway system." The roads, he added, are definitely noticeable. Utah doesn't want to pave them, Fairbanks said. But they should remain open to Snake Valley residents who have used them for generations to reach favorite camping or picnicking areas. WHAT IS RS2477 ? Revised Statute 2477, part of an 1866 mining law, granted rights of way across public land until it was repealed by Congress in 1976. When that happened, existing rights of way were grandfathered in. The definition of "existing" was at the heart of a 2005 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruling that said the U.S. Bureau of Land Management must defer to state law when assessing counties' road-ownership claims. Under Utah law, existing roads are those that had 10 years of continuous use and county maintenance before 1976. Continuous-use claims now must be decided road by road in federal court.
CLEANUP KEEPS KENNECOTT
OFF SUPERFUND LIST After undertaking a $400 million-plus cleanup - with a promise to spend even more - Kennecott will see its south Salt Lake Valley groundwater plume escape Superfund status. Federal and state environmental regulators formally announced the decision Wednesday. Kennecott's South Zone area - stretching across parts of South Jordan and West Jordan to the Oquirrh Mountain foothills - was proposed for Superfund listing in 1994 due to contaminated groundwater and soil near the Bingham Canyon Mine. But officials say the company now has met its obligations under a 13-year-old agreement with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and the Utah Department of Environmental Quality to avoid being forced to clean up the site on regulators' terms. "By taking a cooperative approach to the cleanup under the [agreement], the work was performed more efficiently and cost effectively than if we had used the traditional Superfund process," Andrew Harding, president and CEO of Kennecott Utah Copper, said in a statement. Kennecott officials said Wednesday the tainted areas were mostly historic mining sites and operations, many inherited when the company bought the property. In 1991, under Rio Tinto ownership, Kennecott approached EPA and DEQ with an accelerated-cleanup plan. The three parties signed an accord in September 1995 under which the company agreed to complete numerous cleanup projects on the site. In exchange, EPA agreed to take no further action toward listing the site and to withdraw the Superfund proposal once the cleanup was completed. Kennecott's efforts have included addressing and controlling sources of groundwater contamination and cleaning up the South Jordan evaporation ponds and old mining sites. The company has spent more than $400 million to decontaminate the South and North zones and has signed a long-term legal deal with regulators to continue the work. Kennecott's South site includes the Bingham Mining District in the Oquirrh foothills, about 25 miles southwest of Salt Lake City. Mining activities began there in the 1860s and continue to the present at the large Bingham Canyon open-pit mine. Historic mining operations produced lead, zinc, silver, copper and gold.
BLM SETS ENVIRONMENTAL RULES Utah's Uinta Basin holds a lot of oil shale and some tar sands, but what it will take to turn that potential into petroleum remains a question with no easy answers or time frame. But Utah Republican Sens. Orrin Hatch and Bob Bennett praised the federal Bureau of Land Management, which released a multiyear study Friday that sets environmental rules for development of oil shale and tar sands on 1.9 million acres in eastern Utah, western Colorado and southwestern Wyoming. What is called the "Programmatic Environmental Impact Statement" (PEIS) was required under legislation Hatch attached to the 2005 Energy Policy Act. "A lot of people have been armchair quarterbacking on the environmental aspects of oil-shale development," Hatch said in a news release. "Now we have the official word from the actual experts on how the environment can be protected during oil-shale development." But while Utah Republicans champion oil shale as a key to the nation achieving energy independence, Colorado Democrats, who have succeeded in clamping a moratorium on oil-shale and tar-sands mining, say the technology to economically tap that resource is years away and may never be feasible. Despite mounting political pressure to increase petroleum production, Sen. Ken Salazar, D-Colo., will work to extend the ban on oil-shale and tar-sand development set to expire at month's end. "The BLM itself has said that we are still years away from even knowing whether oil-shale development will be possible on a commercial scale," Salazar said in a statement. "They also report that they have no idea how much power would be required or what effect commercial oil-shale development would have on Western water supplies." Utah's Bennett criticized the congressional moratorium and praised the BLM's new plan. "The only obstacle standing in the way of producing more American oil through this abundant resource is Congress," Bennett said in statement. Even if lawmakers lift the moratorium, the BLM document doesn't appear ready to kick open the door for immediate mining of oil shale. Rather, it sets up a number of critical steps that industry would have to pass before moving forward with production. "The BLM anticipates that the eventual development of the oil-shale and tar-sands resources would proceed in a phased approach," the agency said in its study. Among other things, exploration companies would have to demonstrate they can produce oil from shale or tar sands economically and in a manner that would not upset socioeconomics in surrounding communities. Further, production would have to adhere to tenets outlined in the National Environmental Policy Act. Such development would be barred in about 400,000 acres in the three-state area. Those lands include "wilderness study areas," "wild and scenic rivers" and "areas of critical environmental concern," among others. In 2007, the RAND Corp., a nonprofit policy research institute, estimated the region held 800 billion barrels of recoverable oil. But the oil contained in the shale is kerogen, a waxy hydrocarbon that hasn't undergone the geologic pressure and heat necessary to create petroleum. To extract the oil, the current technology requires strip mining and heating the rock to 1,000 degrees Fahrenheit. This process produces greenhouse gases and requires huge amounts of water. Even if the kerogen could be siphoned economically from the rock in commercial quantities, no U.S. oil refinery currently accepts it for processing. Shell Oil Company is experimenting with technology that heats the ground to 700 degrees for several years so that oil shale can be extracted similar to conventional drilling. Whether that process works, company officials say, won't be known for years. In an earlier interview, Hatch conceded that oil-shale mining would not lower gasoline prices in the near future. – Patty Henetz contributed to this report.
GREENHOUSE GASES: UTAH BACKS REGIONAL 'CAP-AND-TRADE' PLAN The Western Climate Initiative includes Arizona, California, Montana, New Mexico, Oregon, Utah and Washington and Canadian provinces British Columbia, Manitoba, Ontario and Quebec. The group has advanced a plan to reduce global warming pollution by capping greenhouse gas emissions and allowing auctions or trades of credits allocated according to a monitored system. Each state and province will create its own path to the overall goal of reducing emissions to 2005 levels by 2020. In Utah, a panel of interest groups will craft necessary policy for consideration by the 2010 Legislature. All large utilities and industries that emit more than the equivalent of 25,000 metric tons of greenhouse gases must by federal law submit a report on their actual emissions by 2011. The deadline for WCI member states and provinces to implement their cap-and-trade systems is 2012. Utah is joining a regional push to cut greenhouse gas emissions that contribute to global warming through a carbon cap-and-trade program, Gov. Jon Huntsman Jr. announced Tuesday. A proposal crafted through the Western Climate Initiative aims to reduce carbon dioxide and other gas emissions by 15 percent by 2020. But the plan for now is just a framework, "the beginning of extensive discussions that will continue with our Legislature and stakeholders to ensure the design works for Utah," said Dianne Nielson, Huntsman's energy policy adviser. Already, though, some state lawmakers worry that the initiative could hinder the state's economic growth. "We want to protect the environment. We want to protect the air quality and do all those things . . . but we want to make sure that the coal industry and some of these that are important economic drivers for our state" are not harmed, said House Speaker Greg Curtis, R-Sandy, who was briefed on the program Monday. As proposed, the Western Climate Initiative, which includes seven Western states and four Canadian provinces, will use emissions from 2010 as a baseline for cap-and-trade. Beginning in 2012, each partner will be granted emission "allowances" that will move the state to the WCI's goal. It then will be up to each state or province to decide how to distribute its allowance. Carbon "offset" credits from uncapped sectors or entities that reduce emissions could be auctioned. Nielson said that Utah's approach to greenhouse gas reductions would be spelled out in a bill to be written for the 2010 Legislature. A task force - composed of lawmakers, executive branch representatives, industry, utilities, energy producers, consumer groups, environmental advocates, local government and others - would be assembled to nail down the details the bill would include, she said. Under the WCI framework, emissions would be rigorously monitored. If a company, utility or some other entity doesn't have enough allowances to cover its emissions, it could lose some of its allowances as a penalty, forcing it either to buy more credits or cut its emissions. When Huntsman enlisted the state in the Western Climate Initiative in 2007, some lawmakers were irritated that they weren't consulted first. A bill aimed at limiting the governor's power to enter into such agreements in the future passed the Legislature by an overwhelming margin last session, but Huntsman vetoed it and agreed to consult with legislative leaders before he commits the state to future partnerships. Curtis said lawmakers want to know more about the cap-and-trade plan. ''I don't feel like we've been deeply consulted,'' said Curtis, who had a planned meeting on the proposal with the governor Monday, but it was replaced with discussion of the state's $272 million budget shortfall. WCI proponents say that, in addition to reducing emissions, the plan would ease dependence on fossil fuels and spawn new "green" industries. Utah Clean Energy executive director Sarah Wright said Utah's approach likely would be conservative because the state could achieve the "cap" part of the plan largely through an aggressive energy efficiency program Huntsman already has in place. "It's not a sea change in the way we generate and use energy," Wright said. "We're not going to be closing down coal plants." Nielson said the WCI wanted a cap-and-trade plan rather than a carbon tax, which would have been more expensive. "We want it to be an affordable system," she said. "We're looking to be sure we have a diversified energy base, and that includes coal," she said. Britt Weygandt, executive director of the Western Business Roundtable, a pro-industry group, said the organization is still examining the WCI plan. However, he said, a regional cap-and-trade system "would dramatically increase costs to consumers in the West of virtually everything we buy." That's not how the Union of Concerned Scientists sees it. Christopher Bush, a UCS climate economist, said analyses conclude that region's economy would benefit from investments in global warming solutions.
WALL STREET: CRUDE, METAL FUTURES TUMBLE NEW YORK - Investors are fleeing commodities in another huge exodus, reviving debate about whether the futures bubble has burst or is just going through a temporary contraction. A steep drop in oil prices Tuesday started the latest selling wave, and gold, silver, copper and wheat also posted huge losses. The broad decline led to a 270-point swing on the Dow, with the stocks of oil and metals companies sinking and dragging on the broader market. The Dow Jones Industrial Average, up more than 250 points early in the day, finished Tuesday down more than 26 points. ''All of these markets seem to be going hand in hand,'' said Darin Newsom, senior analyst at DTN in Omaha, who called the speed of the pullback ''startling.'' Crude tumbled $5.75 to settle at $109.71 a barrel on the New York Mercantile Exchange after it appeared that Hurricane Gustav struck only a glancing blow to the Gulf of Mexico's offshore energy infrastructure. At one point, oil was down to about $105, the lowest trading level since April 4, just before oil began an unprecedented march above $147 per barrel. The sell-off in oil in turn dragged virtually every major commodity sharply lower as hedge funds and other large institutional investors raced to dump positions. Precious metals prices collapsed. Gold for December delivery fell as much as $40 an ounce on the Nymex before paring its losses to settle $24.70 lower at $810.50. In other Nymex trading, platinum prices lost $86.30, or 4.86 percent, to $1,403.50 an ounce, while silver shed 56.2 cents, or 3.6 percent, to $13.145 an ounce. Copper fell 11.4 cents, or 3.3 percent, to settle at $3.273 a pound. The sell-off comes amid a flurry of bearish moves for commodities. A stronger dollar has eroded the appeal of commodities as a hedge against inflation, and a global economic slowdown is weakening demand for copper, lead, aluminum and other industrial metals. But the declines will give consumers only limited relief; though gasoline prices have come down nationally (though more slowly in Utah) as crude falls, food prices at the grocery aisle have been slower to drop as food companies work through more expensive raw materials. It's a stark turnaround from only a few months ago when prices for oil, gold and grains were touching record highs, driven up by weakness in the U.S. currency and seemingly relentless demand for raw materials. Analysts are split over whether commodities are in the throes of a protracted decline or are simply hibernating before the next boom. Some market watchers say historic run-ups in oil, precious metals and agriculture prices in the first part of the year were mainly speculative-driven rallies that were detached from fundamental supply and demand. In other economic news Tuesday, the Institute for Supply Management said its reading for the nation's manufacturers fell to 49.9 in August from 50 in July, signaling sluggish growth the rest of the year. A reading below 50 signals contraction, while a reading above 50 signals growth. Separately, the Commerce Department said construction spending declined 0.6 percent in July, double the 0.3 percent decrease analysts had expected. Housing activity fell for a 16th consecutive month, declining 2.3 percent to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of $357.8 billion. That was the lowest level since March 2001, the start of the last recession. Nonresidential activity, which had been offsetting some of the weakness in the residential sector, also fell in July, dropping 0.7 percent to an annual rate of $416.8 billion. It was the first setback in that category since December.
FED HOLDS RATES, THEN BAILS OUT AIG NEW YORK - The Federal Reserve resisted a cut in interest rates and then announced it would provide up to $85 billion in an emergency, two-year loan to rescue insurance giant American International Group Inc. In return, the government will get a 79.9 percent stake in AIG and the right to remove senior management. The moves, along with a slight rebound on Wall Street, offered some respite after the chaos that shook the financial system Monday when investment house Lehman Brothers declared the largest bankruptcy in U.S. history and the Dow Jones industrials suffered its biggest point drop since the 2001 terrorist attacks. The Fed said it determined that a disorderly failure of AIG could hurt the already delicate financial markets and the economy. The move was similar to government's seizure on Sept. 7 of mortgage giants Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, where the Treasury Department said it was prepared to put up as much as $100 billion over time in each of the companies if needed to keep them from going broke. Both moves were bound to raise questions about the use of taxpayer money to bail out private firms. AIG is little known off Wall Street but does business with almost every financial institution in the world. It insures $88 billion worth of assets and plays an outsized role insuring mortgages and corporate loans, but even more threatening was its integral role in the murky world of hedge funds and credit derivatives. All three major credit rating agencies had cut AIG's ratings at least two notches Monday night, and although the new ratings were still considered investment grade, they added pressure on AIG as it sought tens of billions of dollars to strengthen its balance sheet. A collapse of AIG would force Wall Street to untangle the complex credit derivatives markets and send the market scrambling to figure out who owes what to whom - or even who owns what. The White House said it backed the Fed's decision Tuesday. After meeting with Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson and Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke in a late-night briefing on Capitol Hill, Congressional leaders said they understood the need for the bailout. The Fed stepped in hours after it decided, in its first unanimous vote this year, to keep the closely watched federal funds rate unchanged at 2 percent. At the same time, however, the Fed noted that strains on the market have ''increased significantly'' and said it was ready to act if needed. Stocks slumped after the Fed announcement. The Dow initially dropped about 100 points but rallied to finish the day up 141, and back over 11,000. As AIG teetered, central bankers around the globe scrambled to revive credit markets. The Fed injected $70 billion into the American financial system. The European Central Bank pumped one-day financing of nearly $100 billion into the 15-nation zone. The Bank of Japan added $24 billion, and England's central bank almost $36 billion. Separately, Bank of America Corp., which in July bought battered Countrywide Financial Corp., began to work out how it would digest its $40 billion acquisition of Merrill Lynch after its shotgun wedding with the brokerage on Sunday. In the wings, Goldman Sachs Group Inc., which began the year as one of five large investment banks and is now one of two, reported its worst profit drop since going public in 1999. Goldman's third-quarter profit dropped 71 percent to $810 million, while revenues plummeted 50 percent. The only other investment bank left standing, Morgan Stanley, had better news. It reported solid quarterly profits - though down 7 percent from a year earlier - and surpassed Wall Street's expectations.
U.S. SEIZES CONTROL OF MORTGAGE GIANTS The government seized control of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac yesterday in a dramatic bid to restore faith in the embattled mortgage giants and arrest a vicious cycle that has driven the nation's economy into a steep downturn. Following weeks of round-the-clock planning, Treasury Secretary Henry M. Paulson Jr. announced the takeover to try to stabilize the deeply troubled housing and financial markets. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, with a combined 11,000 employees, have funded more than two-thirds of U.S. home loans in recent months, and doubts over their ability to continue doing so had threatened to immerse the economy into even more turmoil. With home loans harder to come by, buyers have recently been unable to make purchases, causing the housing market to tank further, leaving banks and other lenders with huge losses. Those losses, in turn, have made loans even harder to get. "Our economy will not recover until the bulk of this housing correction is behind us," Paulson said yesterday. "Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are critical to turning the corner on housing." There is no guarantee that the takeover will work, and it comes at a potentially massive cost to taxpayers. The government has pledged to inject money in the companies in any quarter in which they would otherwise be insolvent -- up to $100 billion in total for each company. "This is a shareholder bailout financed by the U.S. taxpayers," said Armando Falcon Jr., formerly the chief regulator of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. Paulson also announced a separate program in which the government will start buying securities backed by mortgages -- $5 billion worth, initially. That will, in effect, subsidize the purchase of homes by lowering the interest rate that buyers must pay for a mortgage. Paulson said that both the potential investment in Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac and the planned purchase of mortgage-backed securities are designed to protect taxpayers. The government has received $1 billion worth of preferred stock in each company upfront in exchange for the guarantees, for example, and government officials said taxpayers have a good chance of profiting from the purchase of mortgage bonds. The Treasury secretary also named new executives at Fannie and Freddie. Herbert M. Allison Jr., who most recently served as chairman and chief executive of TIAA-CREF -- the pension fund giant serving employees in the academic, medical, cultural and research fields -- will take over at Fannie. David M. Moffett, previously vice chairman and chief financial officer of U.S. Bancorp, will lead Freddie. These are the latest -- and so far, most expensive -- efforts by the government to contain a financial crisis that began in the subprime mortgage market and has metastasized to encompass all types of debt markets. The International Monetary Fund has estimated the global losses will total nearly $1 trillion before the crisis ends. The government should have done more - or did it do too much? Alan Greenspan encouraged a housing boom that was destined to collapse. The White House and Congress were lax in overseeing the captains of finance. People bought homes they couldn't afford. Investors eagerly bought mortgage-backed securities they didn't understand. Human nature was a guiding force in markets that were first driven by greed and then shaken by fear. It turns out there's lots of blame to go around for the spreading financial crisis. And political hay to be made. Financial markets around the world tumbled as the deepening U.S. financial crisis took its biggest casualties. In rapid fire succession over the past three days: Investment bank Lehman Brothers Holdings filed for bankruptcy protection, and fellow longtime Wall Street institution Merrill Lynch agreed to peddle itself in a fire sale to Bank of America. And the world's largest insurance company, American International Group Inc., faced possible restructuring. What had happened? Some seeds of the current crisis were planted in the late 1990s, when Congress and President Clinton reshaped the financial landscape. They removed Depression-era barriers between commercial banks and investment firms and allowed the creation of financial behemoths where, years later, the risks of underwriting risky subprime mortgages were somewhat hidden. McCain voted for a Senate version of the bill but did not vote on the final package. Democratic vice presidential nominee Joe Biden voted against the Senate version but for the final compromise that was signed by Clinton. Jim Leach, an Iowan who was chairman of the House Banking Committee when Congress enacted the overhaul, said he believes the current problems stem mostly from lawmakers' unwillingness to more closely regulate either the mortgage giants Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac or investment banks. That has led to a proliferation of "new Wall Street instruments that came to be sliced and diced to the advantage of short-term profit-taking but long-term liabilities," Leach said in an interview. "Wall Street became better at sales than at financial judgment." But despite now-widespread calls for stricter rules, "regulation will never solve the entire problem," Jones said. "That's because the problem is basically human nature, which will always fluctuate between greed and fear, between euphoria and despair, between complacency and panic. That's always going to happen."
UTAH'S ECONOMIC UPS, DOWNS: Utah released its worst jobs report in five years Tuesday, but an upbeat inflation report provided some hope to consumers battered by a sliding economy. The Utah Department of Workforce Services said overall employment in the state crept up by only 0.3 percent in August over the same month last year. The lowest monthly employment growth rate since August 2003 translates into a gain of 3,260 new jobs over the past year, down substantially from a peak gain of 5.4 percent and 54,000 jobs in the year that ended June 2006. But against the backdrop of that sobering news, the monthly inflation report offered some relief as the slow decline in gasoline prices in Utah provided help to those squeezed by higher prices for food, rents, utilities and health care. In fact, falling fuel costs meant that the consumer price index for the Wasatch Front rose only 0.1 percent from July to August, Wells Fargo & Co. reported Tuesday. That compares with an almost-unheard-of 1.1 percent increase from June to July. Nationally, consumer prices fell 0.1 percent last month after two months of large increases. Just last month, Utahns were paying the third-highest gas prices in the country, significantly above the national average. On Tuesday, the average cost of a gallon of unleaded gasoline in the state was $3.78, down from $4.05 one month ago and a peak of $4.22 July 18, according to travel-services company AAA Utah. The national average is $3.85, with Utah now ranking in the middle among all states in terms of gasoline prices. Utah motorists such as Mike Sorensen of Midvale have seen some sizable drops in just the past few days. Sorensen said he paid $3.73 for regular unleaded three days ago, while the same station on Tuesday was charging $3.67. But Sorensen, like a number of consumers, isn't cheering just yet. "I think pretty soon it's going to go right back up to $4 per gallon," he said gloomily. Economist Kelly Matthews of Wells Fargo & Co. says pump prices could continue their slide if oil prices continue to fall from their peak of around $140 a barrel to around $91 a barrel on Tuesday. Nationally and locally, food prices have yet to fall, but Matthews thinks grocery prices should ease as gasoline prices - and subsequently transportation costs - decrease. "The big break for consumers now is in gasoline," he said. "Lower gasoline prices don't solve all our problems, but combined with lower mortgage rates, it's really good news." The lingering question in the reports out Tuesday is how well Utah's economy will fare in coming months, and whether Utah's job growth and inflation will worsen. Although a number of industry sectors continue to add jobs, they are doing so at a lesser rate than when the state's and nation's economies were booming. And the state's construction industry - along with related sectors such as finance - continue to shed jobs. The manufacturing sector isn't going so great, either, furthering an overall trend toward fewer manufacturing jobs nationally. One bright spot is that commercial construction activity - thanks to such projects as the new skyscraper taking shape at 222 S. Main and the LDS Church's City Creek Center project - is helping make up for some of the loss in home-building activity. And when it comes to creating jobs Utah is doing better than the nation as a whole, which saw growth of negative 0.3 percent for August in contrast with Utah's positive 0.3 percent. And Utah's unemployment rate, though up, was 3.7 percent in August, compared with the national rate of 6.1 percent. Although Utah's employment outlook will continue to weaken, economist Mark Knold of the state's Workforce Services department said he isn't predicting widespread job losses similar to those that have hit other parts of the country. "I believe our unemployment rate will remain below the national average. In Utah, I think the rest of the industries aside from construction, finance and manufacturing are going to stay pretty healthy."
FED REPORT: ECONOMY IS STUCK WASHINGTON - The country is stuck in a slow-growth rut, the Federal Reserve suggested. Higher prices for energy, food and other things are pinching people and businesses - reasons enough for the economy to be Americans' top concern heading into the presidential elections. The Fed's report on business conditions around the nation provided fresh evidence of the toll that housing, credit and financial problems are taking on the economy as a whole. With problems expected to persist into next year, the next president - be it John McCain or Barack Obama - is likely to face many challenges. Heading into the fall, "economic activity has been slow" in most of the Fed's 12 regions, according to the report. Businesses described the climate as "weak" or "soft" or "subdued." A growing number of analysts believe the economy could be thrown into a tailspin later this year and early next year as consumers and businesses curtail their spending even more. "Over the course of this summer it became clear that the economic headwinds have not subsided as hoped," Eric Rosengren, president of the Federal Reserve Bank of Boston, said in a speech Wednesday. The Fed's report noted that consumers - major shapers of the economy - were cautious. Shoppers "concentrated on necessary items and retrenchment in discretionary spending," the Fed observed. The Fed regions of Chicago, Dallas and San Francisco (which includes Utah), for instance, reported noticeable declines in spending on clothing, electronics and jewelry. Sales of furniture and household appliances were weak in most parts of the country - victims of the housing slump. Auto sales, meanwhile, tumbled, according to company reports out Wednesday. Ford Motor Co.'s U.S. sales fell 26.5 percent in August. Sales at General Motors Corp. dropped 20.3 percent from a year ago. Toyota's sales sank 9.4 percent. Wall Street had a mixed reaction to all the news. The Dow Jones industrial average gained 15.96 points to close at 11,532.88. Other stock indexes dipped. Caught between dueling concerns of slow growth and inflation, the Fed is expected to leave a key interest rate alone at 2 percent when it meets next on Sept. 16 and probably through the rest of this year. With the Fed on hold, Democratic presidential nominee Obama has called for a second round of government stimulus, while his GOP rival McCain has favored free-trade and other business measures to spur the economy. In a separate report, the Commerce department said orders placed iwth U.S. factories rose 1.3 percent in July as demand for commercial aircraft, hevay machinery and iron and steel all posted gains. Factories have been helped by the drooping value of the dollar, which makes U.S.-made goods cheaper and more attractive to foreign buyers. That also has helped to boost overall export growth.
NEW HOME SALES FALL IN AUGUST WASHINGTON (AP) -- Weekly jobless claims surged to the highest level in seven years, durable goods orders took a bigger-than-expected tumble and new home sales plunged to the slowest pace in 17 years, according to government data released. The latest trifecta of bad news about the economy raised new worries about a possible recession and underscored the concerns that are driving Congress and the White House to reach agreement on an historic bailout of the financial system. The Labor Department reported that jobless claims jumped by 32,000 to a seasonally adjusted 493,000 last week, the highest level since shortly after the Sept. 11, 2001 terrorist attacks and far above what economists had been expecting. Labor Department analysts said that Hurricanes Ike and Gustav added about 50,000 claims, but even discounting the adverse impact from job disruptions in Louisiana and Texas, the four-week average for claims rose to 445,000, the highest it has been since November 2001, the month the last recession ended. In a second report, the Commerce Department said that new orders to factories for big-ticket manufactured goods fell by 4.5 percent last month, led by a big drop in demand for airplanes but also reflecting weakness in everything from autos to primary metals and machinery. The third weaker-than-expected report showed that new home sales plunged by 11.5 percent in August, a much bigger decline than the 1 percent dip that had been expected. It pushed sales down to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 460,000, the slowest pace since January 1991.
JOBLESS RATE AT HIGHEST IN 5 YEARS WASHINGTON – The nation's unemployment rate bolted above the psychologically important 6 percent level last month for the first time in five years – and it's likely to go even higher, possibly throwing the economy into a tailspin as Americans pick a new president. A blizzard of pink slips propelled the jobless rate from 5.7 percent in July to 6.1 percent in August, the Labor Department reported yesterday. Such a sharp increase is usually a strong recession warning, and it dashed investors' hopes for a late-year recovery. Worried about the economy and their own business prospects, employers cut payrolls by 84,000 in August, marking the eighth straight month of losses. So far this year, 605,000 jobs have vanished. The economy needs to generate more than 100,000 new jobs a month for employment to remain stable. Richard Yamarone, economist at Argus Research, feared that the jobless rate would cause consumers and businesses to "move from a moderately concerned stage to outright fear" and reduce their spending even more. A toxic trio of housing, credit and financial problems has shaken the economy, and the crisis shows no signs of letting up. It's the public's top worry, and many experts believe the situation will get worse before it gets better. The unemployment increase means many companies will feel pressure to reduce their business investments – either in capital projects or hiring – for the rest of the year. "Mix business caution with consumer exhaustion and you have a recipe for a real recession," said Terry Connelly, dean of Golden Gate University's Ageno School of Business. The number of unemployed rose to 9.4 million in August, compared with 7.1 million a year ago. Economists predict more job losses ahead, pushing the unemployment rate to 7 percent by fall of 2009, according to some projections. Against this backdrop, a growing number of analysts predict the economy will jolt into reverse in the final three months of this year and possibly in the first three months of next year, meeting a classic definition of a recession. The economy shrank late last year and barely budged at the start of this year. Growth picked up in the spring, thanks to brisk exports and the government's tax rebates, which energized shoppers at home. But that rebound wasn't expected to last. Slower growth overseas will probably cause exports to fall off just as Americans are cutting their spending and the benefits of the rebates disappear. Job losses were widespread at factories – especially housing-related manufacturers and automakers – as well
Return to Top of Page 2008
6-8 Coal Market Strategies Conference, Kingsmill Golf Resort & Spa, Williamsburg, Virginia. For more info. visit http://www.coalmarketstrategies.com/ 16 Utah Coal Energy Symposium, Western Energy Training Center, Helper, Utah. For more info. visit: http://www.westernenergytraining.org/calendar.php 22-24 Carbon Sequestration Development & Finance Summit, Crowne Plaza Downtown, Houston, TX. For more info. visit http://guest.cvent.com/EVENTS/Info/Summary.aspx?i=76dff04d-7ab1-4206-821a-e8ce7812483b
1-5 Northwest Mining Association Annual Meeting, John Ascuaga's Nugget, Reno, Nevada. For more info. visit: http://www.nwma.org/convention.asp 2-4 Power Gen International 2008, Orlando, Florida. For more info. visit: http://pgi08.events.pennnet.com/fl//index.cfm
| |